You might be wondering what to do if your house doesn’t sell if it’s on the market and you haven’t received any offers that you feel comfortable with. And that’s creating a new problem for an increasing number of homeowners: should I just rent it instead?
In the business world, this is referred to as an accidental landlord. Yahoo Finance defines it as follows:
“These ‘accidental landlords’ are homeowners who have chosen to rent out their houses until things improve after trying to sell but failing to get the price they desired.”
Why This Is Happening More Often Right Now
Additionally, more and more homeowners are becoming unintentional landlords at the moment. Why is explained by Business Insider:
Although there have always been unintentional landlords, a period of mediocre home sales due to a sharp increase in borrowing costs is creating a new generation of hesitant landlords.
In essence, as consumers grapple with today’s affordability issues, sales have slowed. As a result, some homeowners have listings that remain stale. Additionally, they might choose to rent rather than try to attract buyers by lowering their price.
However, if you’ve considered renting your home, here’s something to keep in mind. There’s probably a reason why you didn’t initially intend to become a landlord. It entails far more risk and responsibility than most people realize.
Therefore, if you find yourself considering that option, start by asking yourself these questions:
1. Does Your House Have Potential as a Profitable Rental?
You should not rent just because you are able to. For instance:
- Will you be relocating out of state? It’s difficult to oversee maintenance from a distance.
- Before the house is ready for rental use, does it require any repairs? Additionally, do you have the time or money to do that?
- Would your home be profitable as a rental property in a neighborhood that usually draws renters?
Selling might be a better course of action if any of those make you uneasy.
2. Are You Ready To Be a Landlord?
Renting seems like a simple passive income source on paper. In practice, it frequently appears more like this:
- Calls in the middle of the night regarding broken air conditioners or clogged toilets
- Following up on unpaid rent
- You will need to repair any damage between tenants.
As Redfin notes:
Among other necessary repairs, landlords must fix things like damaged structures, broken pipes, and malfunctioning HVAC systems. You might find yourself in a tight spot if you don’t have a few thousand dollars to handle these repairs.
3. Have You Thought Through the True Costs?
Here are some of the hidden expenses associated with renting out your house, per Bankrate:
- An increased premium for insurance (landlord insurance usually costs about 25% more)
- If you hire a property manager, they usually take 10% of the rent as management fees.
- Tenant recruitment through advertising and maintenance
- Tenant gaps, in which you pay the mortgage without receiving any rental income
That adds up quickly.
Renting can be a wise choice for the right person with the right home, but if you’re only thinking about it because your listing didn’t sell, speaking with your current agent and reviewing your home’s pricing plan first might be a better course of action.
By following their guidance, you can adjust your approach, relaunch at the appropriate price, and draw in actual customers to close the deal.
Conclusion
Make sure to carefully consider the benefits and drawbacks of becoming a landlord before deciding to rent your home. Some homeowners might not think the trouble (and cost) is worth it.
FAQs
Is my house a good candidate for a profitable rental?
Not every house is suitable for rental use; it’s crucial to carefully consider whether the property will bring in enough money to pay for expenses and whether local demand will allow for steady occupancy.
What are the main responsibilities of being a landlord?
Landlords have a lot more responsibilities than just collecting rent; they also have to deal with property maintenance, tenant communications, legal matters, and problem-solving quickly.
What financial considerations should be weighed before renting?
To ascertain whether renting is a financially feasible option, potential landlords should consider the expenses of property management, potential vacancies, necessary repairs, property taxes, and insurance.
How do vacancy rates and tenant issues affect potential rental income?
Landlords must budget for downtime because frequent tenant turnover and empty periods can put a strain on their finances.
Should personal circumstances influence the decision to rent or sell?
Changes in financial objectives, long-distance relocation, or life transitions can influence whether a homeowner would be better off selling or renting.

